The Nuclear Option
In what I believe what may have been one of the few treatments of the CBC’s Jian Ghomeshi situation since late October, Q host Wab Kinew interviewed cultural observers Justin Worland and Tyler Coates about how recent allegations of sexual predation against a spate of stars by victimized women has tainted their public persona. For most of the interview, Mr. Kinew seemed to be talking around the CBC’s own nightmare. But at the end, he asked the question I asked in my November 1st blogpost; What will the CBC do with the thousands of hours of conversations recorded by Ghomeshi in his six years as host of the CBC’s flagship arts and entertainment program? And if they air, would the CBC in some way be condoning Ghomeshi’s alleged behavior?
The CBC, according to Mr. Kinew, has decided to not only not replay any of the interviews Mr. Ghomeshi conducted, but it is apparently in the process of removing all of those interviews from its archive. By starting fresh and essentially saying those interviews never happened, the CBC has chosen the nuclear option. The discussion was mostly good yesterday memories v bad today news stories; not my focus here. Besides, both guests had different opinions over how they see the current situation and how they recall questionable behavior from Roman Polanski through Woody Allen, Bill Cosby, Ray Rice to Jian Ghomeshi. It’s a split I suspect divides listeners as well. Loyalists for these famous men will probably continue to give them the benefit of the doubt. And in a democratic society, that is their right.
As of this post, only two people had commented on today’s conversation. And both of them were against deleting the archives. They feel people should have the choice to listen or not. That only two people commented on a story that, a month and a half ago, split Q’s massive audience down the middle does seem to say that people, in large part, have moved on.
It is interesting that both men seem to praise the writers and producers of the Cosby Show and the good work they did even if Bill Cosby’s name is the prominent one. They are kind to the show and say it has much to give future generations in terms of its messages of positive family life. I feel the same way about many of Qs hard working producers who sweated bullets to get some of the best interviews of their careers only to know they have essentially been erased from history.
My focus is the cultural loss that was balanced against the moral outrage. The fact that CBC is going to essentially burn thousands of hours of interviews from legendary luminaries whose voices, many of which will never be heard again, says they don’t have much of an appetite for ambiguity.
Fire and forget.